{ "ab_accounting": { "best_bid_ask": { "boundary_dropped": 43, "class": "PARTIAL", "exception_markets": 53043, "rows_by_domain": { "c": 0, "g": 0, "h": 11998689, "i": 11461831, "k": 11437546 }, "rows_c": 0, "rows_g": 0, "rows_h": 11998689, "rows_i": 11461831, "rows_joined": 12002048, "rows_k": 11437546, "rows_merged": 12002005, "unique_by_domain": { "c": 0, "g": 0, "h": 457660, "i": 302, "k": 1567 }, "witness_latency": { "h": { "buckets_ms": { "0_1ms": 0, "10000_30000ms": 22159, "1000_2000ms": 38695, "100_200ms": 220620, "10_20ms": 7695964, "1_2ms": 0, "2000_5000ms": 38868, "200_500ms": 252872, "20_50ms": 3055118, "2_5ms": 0, "5000_10000ms": 25483, "500_1000ms": 108795, "50_100ms": 528619, "5_10ms": 0, "ge30000ms": 11496, "neg": 0 }, "max_ms": 74589, "mean_ms": 138.32401806564033, "measurable": 11998689, "min_ms": 14, "p50_ms": 19.0, "p90_ms": 52.0, "p99_ms": 1259.0, "rows": 11998689, "unmeasurable": 0, "won_output_rows": 1313173 }, "i": { "buckets_ms": { "0_1ms": 0, "10000_30000ms": 152, "1000_2000ms": 2533, "100_200ms": 201596, "10_20ms": 4164027, "1_2ms": 0, "2000_5000ms": 565, "200_500ms": 131102, "20_50ms": 6567432, "2_5ms": 0, "5000_10000ms": 104, "500_1000ms": 10973, "50_100ms": 383347, "5_10ms": 0, "ge30000ms": 0, "neg": 0 }, "max_ms": 13909, "mean_ms": 29.29369225562652, "measurable": 11461831, "min_ms": 15, "p50_ms": 20.0, "p90_ms": 34.0, "p99_ms": 229.0, "rows": 11461831, "unmeasurable": 0, "won_output_rows": 602177 }, "k": { "buckets_ms": { "0_1ms": 0, "10000_30000ms": 946, "1000_2000ms": 6892, "100_200ms": 191371, "10_20ms": 9801620, "1_2ms": 0, "2000_5000ms": 2997, "200_500ms": 162705, "20_50ms": 959240, "2_5ms": 0, "5000_10000ms": 1349, "500_1000ms": 24011, "50_100ms": 286301, "5_10ms": 0, "ge30000ms": 114, "neg": 0 }, "max_ms": 64504, "mean_ms": 27.811667904985914, "measurable": 11437546, "min_ms": 10, "p50_ms": 13.0, "p90_ms": 27.0, "p99_ms": 284.0, "rows": 11437546, "unmeasurable": 0, "won_output_rows": 10086655 } } }, "book": { "boundary_dropped": 10, "class": "PARTIAL", "exception_markets": 214526, "rows_by_domain": { "c": 0, "g": 0, "h": 144268, "i": 630547, "k": 576608 }, "rows_c": 0, "rows_g": 0, "rows_h": 144268, "rows_i": 630547, "rows_joined": 717254, "rows_k": 576608, "rows_merged": 717244, "unique_by_domain": { "c": 0, "g": 0, "h": 12649, "i": 125273, "k": 72148 }, "witness_latency": { "h": { "buckets_ms": { "0_1ms": 0, "10000_30000ms": 2278, "1000_2000ms": 1536, "100_200ms": 5225, "10_20ms": 19841, "1_2ms": 0, "2000_5000ms": 3694, "200_500ms": 5309, "20_50ms": 71776, "2_5ms": 0, "5000_10000ms": 1868, "500_1000ms": 2134, "50_100ms": 11547, "5_10ms": 0, "ge30000ms": 19060, "neg": 0 }, "max_ms": 10272165533, "mean_ms": 33520483.134062994, "measurable": 144268, "min_ms": 15, "p50_ms": 27.0, "p90_ms": 747822.0, "p99_ms": 847799350.2799077, "rows": 144268, "unmeasurable": 0, "won_output_rows": 26873 }, "i": { "buckets_ms": { "0_1ms": 0, "10000_30000ms": 27833, "1000_2000ms": 6057, "100_200ms": 6325, "10_20ms": 16658, "1_2ms": 0, "2000_5000ms": 12540, "200_500ms": 7792, "20_50ms": 70626, "2_5ms": 0, "5000_10000ms": 12800, "500_1000ms": 5491, "50_100ms": 11341, "5_10ms": 0, "ge30000ms": 453084, "neg": 0 }, "max_ms": 10272016997, "mean_ms": 184926685.07704422, "measurable": 630547, "min_ms": 16, "p50_ms": 2140993.0, "p90_ms": 341022212.0, "p99_ms": 2958509789.42, "rows": 630547, "unmeasurable": 0, "won_output_rows": 140442 }, "k": { "buckets_ms": { "0_1ms": 0, "10000_30000ms": 24312, "1000_2000ms": 4750, "100_200ms": 5023, "10_20ms": 74389, "1_2ms": 0, "2000_5000ms": 11633, "200_500ms": 5565, "20_50ms": 23547, "2_5ms": 0, "5000_10000ms": 11160, "500_1000ms": 3194, "50_100ms": 7003, "5_10ms": 0, "ge30000ms": 406032, "neg": 0 }, "max_ms": 10270111300, "mean_ms": 180902507.91663486, "measurable": 576608, "min_ms": 10, "p50_ms": 1591546.5, "p90_ms": 340610549.0, "p99_ms": 2957228227.0, "rows": 576608, "unmeasurable": 0, "won_output_rows": 549929 } } }, "last_trade_price": { "boundary_dropped": 0, "class": "PARTIAL", "exception_markets": 4255, "rows_by_domain": { "c": 0, "g": 0, "h": 57940, "i": 55528, "k": 55487 }, "rows_c": 0, "rows_g": 0, "rows_h": 57940, "rows_i": 55528, "rows_joined": 58241, "rows_k": 55487, "rows_merged": 58241, "unique_by_domain": { "c": 0, "g": 0, "h": 2115, "i": 13, "k": 105 }, "witness_latency": { "h": { "buckets_ms": { "0_1ms": 0, "10000_30000ms": 162, "1000_2000ms": 305, "100_200ms": 2392, "10_20ms": 24849, "1_2ms": 0, "2000_5000ms": 271, "200_500ms": 2432, "20_50ms": 22130, "2_5ms": 0, "5000_10000ms": 159, "500_1000ms": 868, "50_100ms": 4352, "5_10ms": 0, "ge30000ms": 20, "neg": 0 }, "max_ms": 58031, "mean_ms": 159.91097687262686, "measurable": 57940, "min_ms": 15, "p50_ms": 20.0, "p90_ms": 125.0, "p99_ms": 2342.220000000001, "rows": 57940, "unmeasurable": 0, "won_output_rows": 7354 }, "i": { "buckets_ms": { "0_1ms": 0, "10000_30000ms": 48, "1000_2000ms": 407, "100_200ms": 2342, "10_20ms": 10129, "1_2ms": 0, "2000_5000ms": 156, "200_500ms": 2441, "20_50ms": 35121, "2_5ms": 0, "5000_10000ms": 22, "500_1000ms": 1092, "50_100ms": 3770, "5_10ms": 0, "ge30000ms": 0, "neg": 0 }, "max_ms": 13865, "mean_ms": 88.41543005330644, "measurable": 55528, "min_ms": 16, "p50_ms": 22.0, "p90_ms": 128.0, "p99_ms": 1075.1899999999878, "rows": 55528, "unmeasurable": 0, "won_output_rows": 3217 }, "k": { "buckets_ms": { "0_1ms": 0, "10000_30000ms": 1, "1000_2000ms": 56, "100_200ms": 1792, "10_20ms": 42415, "1_2ms": 0, "2000_5000ms": 83, "200_500ms": 1420, "20_50ms": 6755, "2_5ms": 0, "5000_10000ms": 2, "500_1000ms": 242, "50_100ms": 2721, "5_10ms": 0, "ge30000ms": 0, "neg": 0 }, "max_ms": 22177, "mean_ms": 39.47639987744877, "measurable": 55487, "min_ms": 10, "p50_ms": 14.0, "p90_ms": 59.0, "p99_ms": 417.0, "rows": 55487, "unmeasurable": 0, "won_output_rows": 47670 } } }, "market_resolved": { "boundary_dropped": 0, "class": "PARTIAL", "exception_markets": 670, "rows_by_domain": { "c": 0, "g": 0, "h": 670, "i": 670, "k": 670 }, "rows_c": 0, "rows_g": 0, "rows_h": 670, "rows_i": 670, "rows_joined": 744, "rows_k": 670, "rows_merged": 744, "unique_by_domain": { "c": 0, "g": 0, "h": 27, "i": 46, "k": 1 }, "witness_latency": { "h": { "buckets_ms": { "0_1ms": 0, "10000_30000ms": 13, "1000_2000ms": 1, "100_200ms": 14, "10_20ms": 305, "1_2ms": 0, "2000_5000ms": 1, "200_500ms": 19, "20_50ms": 201, "2_5ms": 0, "5000_10000ms": 0, "500_1000ms": 7, "50_100ms": 61, "5_10ms": 0, "ge30000ms": 48, "neg": 0 }, "max_ms": 61620, "mean_ms": 4284.555223880597, "measurable": 670, "min_ms": 15, "p50_ms": 20.0, "p90_ms": 611.1, "p99_ms": 56917.55, "rows": 670, "unmeasurable": 0, "won_output_rows": 103 }, "i": { "buckets_ms": { "0_1ms": 0, "10000_30000ms": 0, "1000_2000ms": 0, "100_200ms": 17, "10_20ms": 203, "1_2ms": 0, "2000_5000ms": 0, "200_500ms": 15, "20_50ms": 342, "2_5ms": 0, "5000_10000ms": 0, "500_1000ms": 1, "50_100ms": 62, "5_10ms": 0, "ge30000ms": 30, "neg": 0 }, "max_ms": 320226, "mean_ms": 8520.035820895522, "measurable": 670, "min_ms": 16, "p50_ms": 21.0, "p90_ms": 94.0, "p99_ms": 258226.0, "rows": 670, "unmeasurable": 0, "won_output_rows": 77 }, "k": { "buckets_ms": { "0_1ms": 0, "10000_30000ms": 7, "1000_2000ms": 0, "100_200ms": 9, "10_20ms": 427, "1_2ms": 0, "2000_5000ms": 0, "200_500ms": 12, "20_50ms": 124, "2_5ms": 0, "5000_10000ms": 0, "500_1000ms": 1, "50_100ms": 24, "5_10ms": 0, "ge30000ms": 66, "neg": 0 }, "max_ms": 298356, "mean_ms": 10369.643283582089, "measurable": 670, "min_ms": 11, "p50_ms": 14.0, "p90_ms": 21632.000000000182, "p99_ms": 236356.0, "rows": 670, "unmeasurable": 0, "won_output_rows": 564 } } }, "new_market": { "boundary_dropped": 0, "class": "PARTIAL", "exception_markets": 3361, "rows_by_domain": { "c": 0, "g": 0, "h": 3361, "i": 3428, "k": 3361 }, "rows_c": 0, "rows_g": 0, "rows_h": 3361, "rows_i": 3428, "rows_joined": 4710, "rows_k": 3361, "rows_merged": 4710, "unique_by_domain": { "c": 0, "g": 0, "h": 385, "i": 262, "k": 661 }, "witness_latency": { "h": { "buckets_ms": { "0_1ms": 0, "10000_30000ms": 155, "1000_2000ms": 0, "100_200ms": 612, "10_20ms": 0, "1_2ms": 0, "2000_5000ms": 0, "200_500ms": 813, "20_50ms": 259, "2_5ms": 0, "5000_10000ms": 70, "500_1000ms": 59, "50_100ms": 298, "5_10ms": 0, "ge30000ms": 1095, "neg": 0 }, "max_ms": 1050643, "mean_ms": 140038.68937816127, "measurable": 3361, "min_ms": 22, "p50_ms": 306.0, "p90_ms": 641684.0, "p99_ms": 1049025.8, "rows": 3361, "unmeasurable": 0, "won_output_rows": 1172 }, "i": { "buckets_ms": { "0_1ms": 0, "10000_30000ms": 71, "1000_2000ms": 0, "100_200ms": 802, "10_20ms": 0, "1_2ms": 0, "2000_5000ms": 0, "200_500ms": 481, "20_50ms": 274, "2_5ms": 0, "5000_10000ms": 24, "500_1000ms": 0, "50_100ms": 482, "5_10ms": 0, "ge30000ms": 1294, "neg": 0 }, "max_ms": 1051202, "mean_ms": 147772.54638273045, "measurable": 3428, "min_ms": 22, "p50_ms": 231.5, "p90_ms": 634784.8, "p99_ms": 1042498.9299999999, "rows": 3428, "unmeasurable": 0, "won_output_rows": 1188 }, "k": { "buckets_ms": { "0_1ms": 0, "10000_30000ms": 37, "1000_2000ms": 0, "100_200ms": 315, "10_20ms": 94, "1_2ms": 0, "2000_5000ms": 0, "200_500ms": 343, "20_50ms": 807, "2_5ms": 0, "5000_10000ms": 22, "500_1000ms": 13, "50_100ms": 476, "5_10ms": 0, "ge30000ms": 1254, "neg": 0 }, "max_ms": 2383827, "mean_ms": 199248.8670038679, "measurable": 3361, "min_ms": 15, "p50_ms": 194.0, "p90_ms": 893809.0, "p99_ms": 2375995.0, "rows": 3361, "unmeasurable": 0, "won_output_rows": 2350 } } }, "price_change": { "boundary_dropped": 322, "class": "PARTIAL", "exception_markets": 87119, "rows_by_domain": { "c": 0, "g": 0, "h": 104075270, "i": 99737042, "k": 99582590 }, "rows_c": 0, "rows_g": 0, "rows_h": 104075270, "rows_i": 99737042, "rows_joined": 104191816, "rows_k": 99582590, "rows_merged": 104191494, "unique_by_domain": { "c": 0, "g": 0, "h": 3724668, "i": 2916, "k": 41472 }, "witness_latency": { "h": { "buckets_ms": { "0_1ms": 0, "10000_30000ms": 188692, "1000_2000ms": 414320, "100_200ms": 2453310, "10_20ms": 62619544, "1_2ms": 0, "2000_5000ms": 374366, "200_500ms": 2659362, "20_50ms": 28635002, "2_5ms": 0, "5000_10000ms": 238612, "500_1000ms": 1087752, "50_100ms": 5335556, "5_10ms": 0, "ge30000ms": 68754, "neg": 0 }, "max_ms": 74773, "mean_ms": 132.687565259259, "measurable": 104075270, "min_ms": 14, "p50_ms": 19.0, "p90_ms": 63.0, "p99_ms": 1382.0, "rows": 104075270, "unmeasurable": 0, "won_output_rows": 11605926 }, "i": { "buckets_ms": { "0_1ms": 0, "10000_30000ms": 20564, "1000_2000ms": 157992, "100_200ms": 2370634, "10_20ms": 32797522, "1_2ms": 0, "2000_5000ms": 79922, "200_500ms": 1717570, "20_50ms": 57860046, "2_5ms": 0, "5000_10000ms": 14256, "500_1000ms": 416644, "50_100ms": 4301892, "5_10ms": 0, "ge30000ms": 0, "neg": 0 }, "max_ms": 13984, "mean_ms": 41.918006551668135, "measurable": 99737042, "min_ms": 15, "p50_ms": 21.0, "p90_ms": 45.0, "p99_ms": 379.0, "rows": 99737042, "unmeasurable": 0, "won_output_rows": 5607234 }, "k": { "buckets_ms": { "0_1ms": 0, "10000_30000ms": 10538, "1000_2000ms": 100174, "100_200ms": 1966748, "10_20ms": 82765988, "1_2ms": 0, "2000_5000ms": 47714, "200_500ms": 1573684, "20_50ms": 9673952, "2_5ms": 0, "5000_10000ms": 9780, "500_1000ms": 299406, "50_100ms": 3133664, "5_10ms": 2, "ge30000ms": 940, "neg": 0 }, "max_ms": 64848, "mean_ms": 31.697684685646358, "measurable": 99582590, "min_ms": 9, "p50_ms": 13.0, "p90_ms": 34.0, "p99_ms": 326.0, "rows": 99582590, "unmeasurable": 0, "won_output_rows": 86978334 } } }, "tick_size_change": { "boundary_dropped": 0, "class": "PARTIAL", "exception_markets": 871, "rows_by_domain": { "c": 0, "g": 0, "h": 3484, "i": 3332, "k": 3348 }, "rows_c": 0, "rows_g": 0, "rows_h": 3484, "rows_i": 3332, "rows_joined": 3484, "rows_k": 3348, "rows_merged": 3484, "unique_by_domain": { "c": 0, "g": 0, "h": 136, "i": 0, "k": 0 }, "witness_latency": { "h": { "buckets_ms": { "0_1ms": 0, "10000_30000ms": 0, "1000_2000ms": 4, "100_200ms": 87, "10_20ms": 2116, "1_2ms": 0, "2000_5000ms": 8, "200_500ms": 151, "20_50ms": 908, "2_5ms": 0, "5000_10000ms": 8, "500_1000ms": 28, "50_100ms": 174, "5_10ms": 0, "ge30000ms": 0, "neg": 0 }, "max_ms": 9038, "mean_ms": 68.548794489093, "measurable": 3484, "min_ms": 15, "p50_ms": 19.0, "p90_ms": 73.0, "p99_ms": 644.0, "rows": 3484, "unmeasurable": 0, "won_output_rows": 433 }, "i": { "buckets_ms": { "0_1ms": 0, "10000_30000ms": 0, "1000_2000ms": 0, "100_200ms": 96, "10_20ms": 1021, "1_2ms": 0, "2000_5000ms": 0, "200_500ms": 80, "20_50ms": 1967, "2_5ms": 0, "5000_10000ms": 0, "500_1000ms": 0, "50_100ms": 168, "5_10ms": 0, "ge30000ms": 0, "neg": 0 }, "max_ms": 421, "mean_ms": 34.09723889555822, "measurable": 3332, "min_ms": 16, "p50_ms": 21.0, "p90_ms": 52.0, "p99_ms": 340.0, "rows": 3332, "unmeasurable": 0, "won_output_rows": 203 }, "k": { "buckets_ms": { "0_1ms": 0, "10000_30000ms": 0, "1000_2000ms": 0, "100_200ms": 71, "10_20ms": 2736, "1_2ms": 0, "2000_5000ms": 4, "200_500ms": 100, "20_50ms": 346, "2_5ms": 0, "5000_10000ms": 0, "500_1000ms": 12, "50_100ms": 79, "5_10ms": 0, "ge30000ms": 0, "neg": 0 }, "max_ms": 2300, "mean_ms": 32.367084826762245, "measurable": 3348, "min_ms": 10, "p50_ms": 13.0, "p90_ms": 38.0, "p99_ms": 394.0, "rows": 3348, "unmeasurable": 0, "won_output_rows": 2848 } } } }, "archive_root": "union-staging", "boundary_guard": "cache", "bytes": 1250268437, "file": "2026-09-25T19.parquet", "generated_by": "tools/orderbook_ab/merge_ab.py", "hour": "2026-09-25/19", "hour_utc": "2026-09-25T19:00:00+00:00", "layout": "union-event-sorted-v1", "max_sequence": 62768920503619920, "merger_git_sha": "fcbb28046152741ae3754e951659977da4c8b36e", "min_sequence": 9570149289916447, "products": { "best_bid_ask": { "byte_range": [ 4, 134003355 ], "columns": [ "timestamp_received", "sequence", "timestamp", "market", "asset_id", "best_bid", "best_ask", "spread", "witness_set", "arrival_skew", "source_witness" ], "max_sequence": 62768920503619410, "min_sequence": 9570149289917028, "order_by": [ "market", "asset_id", "timestamp", "sequence" ], "row_count": 12002005, "row_groups": [ 0, 45 ], "sha256": "c2f62747d031d42a1469c14b4d676ad930660b04f8cd765f05aab27273484f11" }, "book": { "byte_range": [ 134003355, 194875363 ], "columns": [ "timestamp_received", "sequence", "timestamp", "market", "asset_id", "bids", "asks", "witness_set", "arrival_skew", "source_witness" ], "max_sequence": 62768920503615308, "min_sequence": 9570149290000808, "order_by": [ "market", "asset_id", "timestamp", "sequence" ], "row_count": 717244, "row_groups": [ 46, 48 ], "sha256": "a16f4c965655d446cb587e815638517e520f2a433691377023d0e4ebbb9462d8" }, "last_trade_price": { "byte_range": [ 194875363, 198280799 ], "columns": [ "timestamp_received", "sequence", "timestamp", "market", "asset_id", "price", "size", "side", "fee_rate_bps", "transaction_hash", "witness_set", "arrival_skew", "source_witness" ], "max_sequence": 62768920503603013, "min_sequence": 9570149290013875, "order_by": [ "market", "asset_id", "timestamp", "sequence" ], "row_count": 58241, "row_groups": [ 49, 49 ], "sha256": "022ce79e7e0d139b91f38465a56995a23fb67ace41cb16b9664fcded91faa245" }, "market_resolved": { "byte_range": [ 198280799, 198388174 ], "columns": [ "timestamp_received", "sequence", "timestamp", "market", "id", "assets_ids", "winning_asset_id", "winning_outcome", "witness_set", "arrival_skew", "source_witness" ], "max_sequence": 62768920502294552, "min_sequence": 9570149293429598, "order_by": [ "market", "id", "timestamp", "sequence" ], "row_count": 744, "row_groups": [ 50, 50 ], "sha256": "f5906742acb0b988abcece463ef85f959eb3ccf48e954927084d6b5b1fe2fcd7" }, "new_market": { "byte_range": [ 198388174, 198893980 ], "columns": [ "timestamp_received", "sequence", "timestamp", "market", "id", "assets_ids", "outcomes", "question", "slug", "witness_set", "arrival_skew", "source_witness" ], "max_sequence": 62768920502328560, "min_sequence": 9570149290491140, "order_by": [ "market", "id", "timestamp", "sequence" ], "row_count": 4710, "row_groups": [ 51, 51 ], "sha256": "33636d9645e4a779504dfe52e561d5f1920fe006ac55892e058638749c90fde6" }, "price_change": { "byte_range": [ 198893980, 1248812617 ], "columns": [ "timestamp_received", "sequence", "timestamp", "market", "asset_id", "price", "size", "side", "best_bid", "best_ask", "witness_set", "arrival_skew", "source_witness" ], "max_sequence": 62768920503619920, "min_sequence": 9570149289916447, "order_by": [ "market", "asset_id", "timestamp", "sequence" ], "row_count": 104191494, "row_groups": [ 52, 449 ], "sha256": "033f59a4ef34aead83b61dac5fd5b0d5e6a965295f673c28e556ddd5de3410f2" }, "tick_size_change": { "byte_range": [ 1248812617, 1248940535 ], "columns": [ "timestamp_received", "sequence", "timestamp", "market", "asset_id", "old_tick_size", "new_tick_size", "witness_set", "arrival_skew", "source_witness" ], "max_sequence": 62768920501398814, "min_sequence": 9570149291736021, "order_by": [ "market", "asset_id", "timestamp", "sequence" ], "row_count": 3484, "row_groups": [ 450, 450 ], "sha256": "ae06fc7ff6f90875e0035944ec1185be2f33b81a9b35d5478b88faa30baf4cad" } }, "row_count": 116977922, "sequence_note": "sequence and timestamp_received are collector-local provenance; where domains carry the same row, the merge keeps the EARLIEST-RECEIVED copy, equal arrivals breaking by registry order (active: h, i, k). The winner is per row, not per hour -- each row names its own in source_witness", "sha256": "957068d3317dd192a5716c6e83457d619c39bc1460722ed9dde59292ce628c77", "skipped_witnesses": { "c": { "alive": false, "listed_utc": "2026-09-25T21:35:13.910816Z", "newest_upload": "2026-09-25T11:20:09.612000Z", "reason": "not_staged" }, "g": { "alive": false, "listed_utc": "2026-09-25T21:35:30.905006Z", "newest_upload": "2026-09-25T15:20:05.378000Z", "reason": "not_staged" } }, "verification": { "note": "A range digest certifies BYTES. That those bytes are that product comes from this manifest and is cross-checkable against the Parquet footer, which is inside the whole-file sha256.", "primary": "sha256sum == .sha256", "secondary": "curl -r - | sha256sum == .products..sha256" }, "witness_stats": "2026-09-25T19.witness_stats.json", "witnesses": "hik", "served_verbatim": true, "served_note": "This hour is the merger's union file, published byte for byte. Hours before the era cutover are rebuilt here from the seven product files and carry one column fewer." }